13 October 2010

Walmart - The New Super Power?

In another discussion for my MBA Ethics class, we had to analyze the non-market issues of Wal Mart. I am no expert on the many issues that Wal Mart has faced and created. From my textbook there seem to be two major thoughts. First, Wal Mart inspires criticism from those who disapprove of their treatment of employees, effect on local small businesses, immense powers of negotiation with large corporations, and damages to the environment.

The second thought is that Wal Mart has to act the way they do in order to have such low prices. The class text had this quote from a Sacramento Bee columnist about Wal Mart unions and, "So for the sake of 250,000 grocery store clerks and baggers and their employers, the other 35 million people in this state are asked to agree to pay billions of dollars more than they ought to for the necessities of life and to deprive themselves of choices that could make their lives better."

Despite my lack of knowlege, I was anxious to post the issue for several reasons.

1) While we were in Costa Rica I discovered that Wal-Mart really does have tremendous power.
Look familiar? Those signs aren't in dollars, they are in Colones. This is the Hipo Mart in Costa Rica. It is owned by Wal Mart. We went there for a cultural lesson one day with the director of the program.
While we were in this expansive store, we saw that most of the products had Wal Mart tags or were made in China. In fact, even much of the store's rice (a key ingredient in many Costa Rican meals) was originally shipped from Asia through Wal Mart. There weren't many Costa Rican products to choose from in the store, though we did find some great chocolate made completely in Costa Rica.

On top of owning these mega marts, Wal Mart has even purchased many of the local grocery stores in Costa Rica. Pali is a grocery chain in Costa Rica that is owned by Wal Mart and even has Wal Mart's logo on some of the in store signs. Pali is known to have the lowest prices of grocery stores.

2) My second thought in posting is that I am curious what your opinion is of Wal Mart. I avoid shopping at Wal Mart for the most part, because I try to support local businesses. I don't want farmers to stop growing fruits and veggies (or rice, Costa Rica) because they can be produced and even shipped cheaper from somewhere else. Avoiding Wal Mart can be a hard thing to do for a penny-pincher like myself, especially in a down economy. While I'm in the confessional box, I recently purchased a most fantastic computer desk at Wal Mart, not available in it's shape or style anywhere else that I could find. And I LOVE it. There, I'm done.

Do you shop Wal Mart?

8 comments:

  1. Hi Katie. Your trip to Costa Rica looked fun, just wanted to say that before I comment.

    I do not buy the argument that Walmart, or other big retailers, must pay low wages/have poor benefits to offer low prices. At many companies, high on the totem pole people make an unimaginable amount of money in wages and bonuses. A responsible company could structure their pay scale so that CEOs and district managers make a competitive wage, yet not obscene amounts of money. Then regular hourly workers could have more benefits and more security and none of this hurts the bottom line.

    Now, for my bias: I don't shop at Walmart. Though, other stores are on my banned list too for a myriad of reasons. I do shop at some stores that carry products I disapprove of, and in these stores I just avoid those products. So maybe I am morally confused. Anyway, at Walmart I feel guilty for contributing to a place that has such a lack of lack of benefits for employees. Also, I worry about product quality. I think many of their non-food are poorly constructed; I would rather buy something more expensive that lasts a while than something cheap I have to replace soon.

    P.S. There was a discussion on NPR today about business schools & ethics. I think it was on Talk of the Nation if you want to find that audio segment on the web.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I wish that I had some strong ethical stance behind why I don't frequent Wal-mart but the truth is even the parking lot gives me anxiety!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm with Amy - no ethical/moral reasons. I go if I'm looking for something specific, but I generally choose elsewhere first. {the Elk Grove Wal-Mart is quite shady!!} :) I really enjoyed your post - well written!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Katie.....I have your recipe for you...It's Kneaders recipe. Email me.
    lillysvenus@hotmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well I'd kill for a Walmart right now, but I probably don't count. . .

    Very interesting post. Your friend Laurinda sure gave an intelligent response. I'm afraid I'm not educated enough about these issues to respond very intelligently or defend my choices well, but for what it's worth, here goes:

    I shopped at Walmart all the time in Utah, and I have never really thought the quality of the domestic products there seemed inferior for the price you are paying. I appreciated the good customer service and the easy "no questions asked" policy about returns.

    However, one thing I never ever buy at Walmart is meat. It's very poor quality, and I would rather pay more and get meat I don't worry about as much. I also love to support local farmers, so I ALWAYS buy in season from roadside stands.

    I have noticed though that Walmart has a lot of enemies. Lots of my neighbors refuse to shop at the one that just got built in Cedar Hills. Maybe I'm a sell out, but I find it to be quite convenient.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I love Wal-Mart and I always have. Maybe because my mom has been taking me there since before I could walk. As a matter of fact, I miss Super Wal-Mart so much right now! All of the other grocery stores are so expensive. Things are seriously a dollar or two more than what I am used to spending. You just can't beat the prices that Wal-Mart has.. and I know people hate Wal-Mart for some of the reasons you posted, but I still love it.

    As for fruits and veggies, Wal-Mart's produce usually sucks. So in the case of that I am all for supporting local food. In fact, I have found this fabulous fruit/veggie market here and it is absolutely wonderful with great prices.. Well that's my two sense on Wal-Mart.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am agree with both points. I do not like how WalMart treats its employees, etc., and up here, some things are cheaper elsewhere and you get better quality. I use wally world, as a LAST resort, though here, where we are limited in our shopping, it's nice to have another choice. glad you are enjoying you classes. love ya.

    ReplyDelete
  8. As a consumer I am allowed to look out for my own self interest. Therefore I shop at whichever store gives me the best price for product, be it Wal-mart or whoever. I am not going to go spend more of my hard earned money somewhere else when I have a great deal at Wal-mart.

    As for treatment of employees, I don't remember anyone being forced to work at any certain place. If you want healthcare and Wal-mart does not provide it, then you should look for a job somewhere else. Wal-mart is not a government program that we are allowed to vote on and dictate how they spend their money. They are a business that chooses how to spend their money to make the most profit. If I were a business owner, I can't say that I would not do the exact same thing.

    On another note I am sad that you are leaving Utah! Hope everything goes well in Sacramento.

    ReplyDelete